Comparison

Tradacy vs PropTally

PropTally helps you compare dozens of prop firms and track them. Tradacy does one thing, the honest net across every firm you already fund. Here is the honest version.

Short answer. PropTally is two tools in one, a firm-comparison directory and a tracker, with broker connections and a free tier. Tradacy is the single honest net number across the firms you fund, with a one-time price and a built-in way to share it. Pick PropTally to shop and compare firms. Pick Tradacy for the clean number you own.

Tradacy This is us

Price

Free for one firm. Pro $7/mo or $59/yr. Lifetime $149.

Free plan

Yes. One firm, unlimited entries, no card.

Pay once

Yes. $149 lifetime, Founder badge for the first 200, then $199.

What it does best

One honest net number across every firm. Simple, ten-second logging.

Connect bank or broker

No. Manual logging or CSV. Nothing to link.

Share your number

Yes. Wrapped story plus Flex, Confession and Receipt cards.

Firms supported

Any firm. You name it, you log it.

PropTally

Price

Free plan. Pro from about $9/mo.

Free plan

Yes.

Pay once

No. Subscription only.

What it does best

Side by side comparison of 30+ firms, plus a cost tracker and tax export.

Connect bank or broker

Yes. Rithmic, MT4/MT5, cTrader.

Share your number

Some shareable stats. No Wrapped-style year story.

Firms supported

30+ in the comparison directory.

Where PropTally is the better choice

If you are still shopping for firms, PropTally's directory is genuinely useful. It puts 30 plus firms side by side so you can weigh fees and rules before you buy a challenge. It also connects to Rithmic, MT4, MT5, and cTrader to pull trades in automatically. If comparing firms and auto-importing trades matter to you, PropTally does both and Tradacy does neither.

Where Tradacy is the better choice

Tradacy is the better pick if you have already chosen your firms and you just want the truth about your money.

One focus. PropTally is a comparison directory and a tracker in one. Tradacy is only the net number, so there is nothing to wade through.
Pay once. The $149 lifetime means you own it. PropTally is a subscription with no lifetime option.
A built-in way to share. Wrapped and the Confession and Flex cards turn your real number into something you can post. PropTally has no Wrapped-style story.
Nothing to connect. Log in ten seconds or import a CSV. No broker login required.

Does Tradacy compare prop firms for me? +

No. Tradacy tracks your real net across the firms you already fund. If you want to compare 30 plus firms before you buy a challenge, PropTally's directory is built for that.

Are both free to start? +

Both have a free plan. Tradacy free is one firm with unlimited entries and no card. Tradacy also offers a $149 lifetime, which PropTally does not.

Does Tradacy connect to my broker? +

No. You log entries in about ten seconds each or import a CSV. PropTally connects to Rithmic, MT4, MT5, and cTrader if auto-import is what you want.

See your real number first.

Add it up free for one firm, no card. Or use the free calculator with no signup at all.

Start free Free calculator

vs Prop Firm Tracker vs PayoutLab vs PropFolio TradeZella PropFirm Sync alternative Am I profitable with prop firms?

Prices and features were checked against each product's own site in June 2026 and can change. Tradacy is independent and not affiliated with PropTally. Names belong to their owners.